I test drove the Smart roadster-coupé 1n 2003 when it first came out in 80 bhp form. The semi-auto box was a real issue – slow, clumsy, automatically changing up when you took the revs up – basically it spoiled the car.
Smart improved the system in subsequent updates so that it was a little quicker, but it was still not convincing.
Brabus altered various things on their version – apart from upping the power, it has an uprated clutch and the changes are quicker and smoother too – the rocking action when changing up under load is far less pronounced.
Because of this I test drove a Brabus Xclusive Roadster-Coupé in June last year. I
still wasn't convinced – if only it had a normal manual change I thought. In July I was able to try my brother's identical car more extensively. I
still wasn't happy.
Smart stopped making the car – BUT there were plans to re-start production under another company. First there was talk of an MG, then an AC roadster based on the Smart was planned – and they intended to fit a
manual gearbox:

I would have been right at the front of the queue if this had come to anything (even if they only made the notchback roadster version and not the more practical Roadster-Coupé) – but this year it became clear that they hadn't been able to get all the finance they needed, so nothing happened*.
It was therefore a case of take or leave the original. The car has so much going for it that I was torn for most of this year, then I decided to try it again.
I wanted it for public road use and, though I normally change gear on a manual box very quickly, it really isn't necessary – in fact most people I've passengered with both on the road and on track don't change gear any faster than the time taken by the Brabus. The problem is that it takes a while to work out how best to use the car. By default, it is auto mode. This can be over-ridden to take control via the paddles or on the lever. Then there are various ideas as to how best to use the throttle when changing: many recommend lifting slightly as you change, but in the Brabus at least it's not so necessary. The time for a change from start by flicking the paddle to finish where the next gear is engaged and driving is around 1 second. As I said, fine for road use and I don't intend to track it – my Exige is certainly better suited for that – though I may get my daughter (who is just about to start driving) to take it to an advanced driving course at Hockenheim next year – and go in the Exige myself
I've just been out in the car today. With my thumbs on the spokes of the wheel, my finger tips are on the paddles. Click, click, click, click – up the box it goes at my bidding and with minimal effort. 11°C outside. Amazingly powerful heater soon has the car snug. Light, keen steering eager to follow any twisty road I can offer. Small dimensions mean plenty of room to go fast even on narrow roads. As I said in my first post, it uses almost no fuel – fun doesn't come much cheaper! I like it – and the semi-auto box is not the problem I had feared it might be.
I have to say I really regret not having bought one earlier – it was a taste that took a little longer to acquire than most, but that is not unusual for a gourmet item
*As I understand it, all the tooling for the roadster has now been sold to a company in India. Who knows what might yet happen – maybe it will even be ressurected as an electric fun car...